Best Mystery Movies on Hulu in the US

1. 1
   Memento 2000

   Directed by Christopher Nolan · Streaming on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
   8.2

   8.2 · 17K votes
2. 2
   The Sixth Sense 1999

   Directed by M. Night Shyamalan · Streaming on Netflix, Apple TV, Hulu
   7.9

   8.0 · 14K votes
3. 3
   The Secret in Their Eyes 2009

   Directed by Juan José Campanella · Streaming on Hulu
   7.9

   8.0 · 3K votes
4. 4
   Donnie Darko 2001

   Directed by Richard Kelly · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, fuboTV
   7.8

   7.8 · 14K votes
5. 5
   Where the Crawdads Sing 2022

   Directed by Olivia Newman · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
   7.5

   7.5 · 2.4K votes
6. 6
   Scream 1996

   Directed by Wes Craven · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, Paramount Plus Premium
   7.4

   7.4 · 8.3K votes
7. 7
   Missing 2023

   Directed by Will Merrick · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
   7.3

   7.4 · 1.4K votes
8. 8
   Hereditary 2018

   Directed by Ari Aster · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max
   7.3

   7.3 · 9K votes
9. 9
   Midsommar 2019

   Directed by Ari Aster · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max
   7.1

   7.1 · 8.6K votes
10. 10
    The Accountant² 2025

    Directed by Gavin O'Connor · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
    7.0

    7.1 · 2K votes
11. 11
    It Was Just an Accident 2025

    Directed by Jafar Panahi · Streaming on Hulu, Kanopy
    7.0

    7.1 · 709 votes
12. 12
    Barbarian 2022

    Directed by Zach Cregger · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV
    6.9

    6.9 · 3.6K votes
13. 13
    Sinister 2012

    Directed by Scott Derrickson · Streaming on Hulu, Peacock Premium, Kanopy
    6.9

    6.9 · 6.3K votes
14. 14
    Uncharted 2022

    Directed by Ruben Fleischer · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
    6.9

    6.9 · 7.2K votes
15. 15
    Wicked Little Letters 2024

    Directed by Thea Sharrock · Streaming on Hulu, YouTube TV
    6.8

    6.9 · 744 votes
16. 16
    The Bob's Burgers Movie 2022

    Directed by Loren Bouchard · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
    6.8

    7.0 · 398 votes
17. 17
    Kishkindha Kaandam 2024

    Directed by Dinjith Ayyathan · Streaming on Hulu
    6.8

    7.8 · 64 votes
18. 18
    No Exit 2022

    Directed by Damien Power · Streaming on Hulu
    6.8

    6.8 · 1.4K votes
19. 19
    The Home 2025

    Directed by James DeMonaco · Streaming on Hulu, Starz
    6.7

    6.9 · 338 votes
20. 20
    From Hell 2001

    Directed by Albert Hughes · Streaming on Hulu, Tubi TV
    6.7

    6.7 · 3.1K votes
21. 21
    Oddity 2024

    Directed by Damian McCarthy · Streaming on Hulu, Philo, AMC Plus
    6.7

    6.7 · 946 votes
22. 22
    Chithha 2023

    Directed by S. U. Arunkumar · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
    6.6

    7.7 · 41 votes
23. 23
    Boston Strangler 2023

    Directed by Matt Ruskin · Streaming on Hulu
    6.6

    6.6 · 885 votes
24. 24
    Sleep 2023

    Directed by Jason Yu · Streaming on Hulu, Kanopy
    6.6

    6.7 · 269 votes
25. 25
    A Haunting in Venice 2023

    Directed by Kenneth Branagh · Streaming on Hulu
    6.5

    6.6 · 3K votes
26. 26
    The Pledge 2001

    Directed by Sean Penn · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, fuboTV
    6.5

    6.6 · 1.3K votes
27. 27
    Psycho Killer 2026

    Directed by Gavin Polone · Streaming on Hulu
    6.5

    6.7 · 260 votes
28. 28
    The Unholy 2021

    Directed by Evan Spiliotopoulos · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
    6.5

    6.5 · 2.3K votes
29. 29
    Super Troopers 2001

    Directed by Jay Chandrasekhar · Streaming on Hulu
    6.5

    6.5 · 1.3K votes
30. 30
    Longlegs 2024

    Directed by Osgood Perkins · Streaming on Hulu, Kanopy
    6.5

    6.5 · 3K votes
31. 31
    Scream 2 1997

    Directed by Wes Craven · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, Paramount Plus Premium
    6.5

    6.5 · 5K votes
32. 32
    The Village 2004

    Directed by M. Night Shyamalan · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, FXNow
    6.5

    6.5 · 4.8K votes
33. 33
    Inspector Sun and the Curse of the Black Widow 2022

    Directed by Julio Soto Gurpide · Streaming on Hulu, Hoopla
    6.5

    6.7 · 157 votes
34. 34
    Life 2017

    Directed by Daniel Espinosa · Streaming on Hulu, Tubi TV, Sony Pictures Core
    6.5

    6.5 · 8.2K votes
35. 35
    Thanksgiving 2023

    Directed by Eli Roth · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, HBO Max
    6.4

    6.5 · 1.7K votes
36. 36
    Muzzle: City of Wolves 2025

    Directed by John Stalberg Jr. · Streaming on Hulu, Philo, AMC Plus
    6.4

    6.6 · 166 votes
37. 37
    Death on the Nile 2022

    Directed by Kenneth Branagh · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
    6.4

    6.4 · 4.4K votes
38. 38
    Strange Harvest 2025

    Directed by Stuart Ortiz · Streaming on Hulu
    6.3

    6.6 · 93 votes
39. 39
    See How They Run 2022

    Directed by Tom George · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
    6.3

    6.3 · 1.4K votes
40. 40
    My Home Hero the Movie 2024

    Directed by Takahiro Aoyama · Streaming on Hulu
    6.3

    8.1 · 13 votes
41. 41
    Cult Killer 2024

    Directed by Jon Keeyes · Streaming on Hulu
    6.3

    6.4 · 196 votes
42. 42
    Agatha Christie's Seven Dials Mystery 1981

    Directed by Tony Wharmby · Streaming on Hulu, Britbox, BritBox
    6.3

    6.9 · 29 votes
43. 43
    Blood 2023

    Directed by Brad Anderson · Streaming on Hulu
    6.3

    6.3 · 265 votes
44. 44
    Greedy People 2024

    Directed by Potsy Ponciroli · Streaming on Hulu, Lionsgate+, Starz
    6.2

    6.3 · 304 votes
45. 45
    Bordertown 2007

    Directed by Gregory Nava · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, fuboTV
    6.2

    6.3 · 373 votes
46. 46
    Force of Nature: The Dry 2 2024

    Directed by Robert Connolly · Streaming on Hulu, Philo, AMC Plus
    6.2

    6.3 · 302 votes
47. 47
    The Empty Man 2020

    Directed by David Prior · Streaming on Hulu, fuboTV, YouTube TV
    6.2

    6.2 · 1.1K votes
48. 48
    Hypnotic 2023

    Directed by Robert Rodriguez · Streaming on Hulu
    6.2

    6.2 · 1.6K votes
49. 49
    Why Didn't They Ask Evans? 1980

    Directed by John Davies · Streaming on Hulu, Britbox, BritBox
    6.2

    6.7 · 18 votes
50. 50
    The Secret Adversary 1983

    Directed by Tony Wharmby · Streaming on Hulu, Britbox, BritBox
    6.1

    6.9 · 11 votes

Smart score = (votes × rating + 82 × 6.03) ÷ (votes + 82): the TMDB rating, pulled toward the catalog average as if every film had 82 extra average votes. Streaming data by JustWatch.

1. 1
   Hallow Road 2025

   Directed by Babak Anvari · Streaming on Hulu
   6.1

   6.1 · 281 votes
2. 2
   Prisoner's Daughter 2023

   Directed by Catherine Hardwicke · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, Kanopy
   6.1

   6.2 · 86 votes
3. 3
   Daniel Isn't Real 2019

   Directed by Adam Egypt Mortimer · Streaming on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
   6.1

   6.1 · 258 votes
4. 4
   Signal One 2026

   Directed by Jonathan Sobol · Streaming on Hulu
   6.0

   6.1 · 88 votes
5. 5
   The Actor 2025

   Directed by Duke Johnson · Streaming on Hulu, Kanopy
   6.0

   6.1 · 23 votes
6. 6
   Amelia’s Children 2024

   Directed by Gabriel Abrantes · Streaming on Hulu, Kanopy, Hoopla
   6.0

   6.0 · 166 votes
7. 7
   Mercy Road 2023

   Directed by John Curran · Streaming on Hulu, Hoopla
   6.0

   5.9 · 13 votes
8. 8
   Stowaway 2022

   Directed by Declan Whitebloom · Streaming on Hulu, The Roku Channel, YouTube Free
   6.0

   6.0 · 109 votes
9. 9
   Brothers Under Fire 2026

   Directed by Justin Chadwick · Streaming on Hulu, Kanopy
   6.0

   5.9 · 66 votes
10. 10
    No Me Sigas 2025

    Directed by Ximena García Lecuona · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu
    6.0

    5.9 · 71 votes