Best Mystery Movies on Amazon Prime Video in the US

The top 50 of 1,116 mystery movies streaming on Amazon Prime Video in the US, ranked by smart score, updated October 24, 2026.

Slice all 1,116 yourself →

1
Memento 2000
Directed by Christopher Nolan · Streaming on Netflix, Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
8.2
8.2 · 17K votes
2
Witness for the Prosecution 1957
Directed by Billy Wilder · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Kanopy, Hoopla
8.1
8.2 · 1.8K votes
3
The Thing 1982
Directed by John Carpenter · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Philo, AMC Plus
8.1
8.1 · 8.4K votes
4
The Sheep Detectives 2026
Directed by Kyle Balda · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.8
7.9 · 1.8K votes
5
L.A. Confidential 1997
Directed by Curtis Hanson · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.8
7.8 · 5.8K votes
6
Donnie Darko 2001
Directed by Richard Kelly · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, fuboTV
7.8
7.8 · 14K votes
7
Anatomy of a Murder 1959
Directed by Otto Preminger · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, Fawesome
7.7
7.8 · 1.2K votes
8
Charade 1963
Directed by Stanley Donen · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, JustWatch TV Free, fuboTV
7.6
7.7 · 1.6K votes
9
Exhuma 2024
Directed by Jang Jae-hyun · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, AMC Plus, AMC+
7.5
7.7 · 853 votes
10
Laura 1944
Directed by Otto Preminger · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, YouTube TV
7.5
7.6 · 956 votes
11
The Girl with the Dragon Tattoo 2009
Directed by Niels Arden Oplev · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, AMC+
7.5
7.5 · 3.4K votes
12
The Name of the Rose 1986
Directed by Jean-Jacques Annaud · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, The CW
7.5
7.5 · 3.4K votes
13
The Body 2012
Directed by Oriol Paulo · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Kanopy, Hoopla
7.4
7.5 · 1.5K votes
14
Gone Mom: The Disappearance of Jennifer Dulos 2021
Directed by Gail Harvey · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hoopla, Lifetime Movie Club
7.4
7.8 · 241 votes
15
The Lady Vanishes 1938
Directed by Alfred Hitchcock · Streaming on JustWatch TV Free, fuboTV, Philo
7.3
7.4 · 1.1K votes
16
The Long Goodbye 1973
Directed by Robert Altman · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hoopla, Fandango at Home Free
7.3
7.4 · 832 votes
17
Blow Out 1981
Directed by Brian De Palma · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, Hoopla
7.3
7.3 · 1.8K votes
18
Hereditary 2018
Directed by Ari Aster · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max
7.3
7.3 · 9K votes
19
Weapons 2025
Directed by Zach Cregger · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, HBO Max, Howdy
7.3
7.3 · 4.2K votes
20
Eastern Promises 2007
Directed by David Cronenberg · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.3
7.3 · 3.9K votes
21
Glengarry Glen Ross 1992
Directed by James Foley · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, Kanopy
7.3
7.3 · 1.7K votes
22
The Witch: Part 2. The Other One 2022
Directed by Park Hoon-jung · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Philo, The Roku Channel
7.2
7.4 · 491 votes
23
A Day 2017
Directed by Cho Sun-ho · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Plex, Plex Channel
7.2
7.7 · 198 votes
24
Drishyam 2 2022
Directed by Abhishek Pathak · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.2
8.0 · 122 votes
25
Videodrome 1983
Directed by David Cronenberg · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.2
7.3 · 2.6K votes
26
The 39 Steps 1935
Directed by Alfred Hitchcock · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, JustWatch TV Free, HBO Max
7.2
7.3 · 1.1K votes
27
Memoir of a Murderer 2017
Directed by Won Shin-yun · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, Hoopla
7.2
7.4 · 407 votes
28
The Imposter 2012
Directed by Bart Layton · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Philo, The Roku Channel
7.2
7.3 · 828 votes
29
Gonjiam: Haunted Asylum 2018
Directed by Jung Bum-shik · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Philo, AMC Plus
7.2
7.3 · 1K votes
30
Midsommar 2019
Directed by Ari Aster · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu, HBO Max
7.1
7.1 · 8.6K votes
31
Blood and Black Lace 1964
Directed by Mario Bava · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Philo, Hoopla
7.1
7.3 · 489 votes
32
Pi 1998
Directed by Darren Aronofsky · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, JustWatch TV Free, JustWatch TV Plus
7.1
7.1 · 2.6K votes
33
Death on the Nile 1978
Directed by John Guillermin · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, The Roku Channel
7.1
7.2 · 964 votes
34
Good Boy 2026
Directed by Jan Komasa · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Kanopy, Hoopla
7.1
7.3 · 361 votes
35
The Passenger 1975
Directed by Michelangelo Antonioni · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Fawesome, Tubi TV
7.1
7.2 · 568 votes
36
Jai Bhim 2021
Directed by T. J. Gnanavel · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.0
7.4 · 260 votes
37
The Accountant² 2025
Directed by Gavin O'Connor · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
7.0
7.1 · 2K votes
38
The Wrecking Crew 2026
Directed by Ángel Manuel Soto · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
7.0
7.1 · 1.3K votes
39
Ratsasan 2018
Directed by Ram Kumar · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Sun Nxt
7.0
7.4 · 211 votes
40
The Girl Who Kicked the Hornet's Nest 2009
Directed by Daniel Alfredson · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, AMC+, MZ Choice
7.0
7.1 · 1.5K votes
41
Mercy 2026
Directed by Timur Bekmambetov · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, MGM+
7.0
7.1 · 1.8K votes
42
The Bird with the Crystal Plumage 1970
Directed by Dario Argento · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Kanopy, Hoopla
7.0
7.1 · 870 votes
43
The Witch 2016
Directed by Robert Eggers · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Plex Channel
7.0
7.0 · 8K votes
44
The Unknown Woman 2006
Directed by Giuseppe Tornatore · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, Hoopla
7.0
7.2 · 380 votes
45
Arlington Road 1999
Directed by Mark Pellington · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, The Roku Channel
7.0
7.0 · 1.3K votes
46
The Girl Who Played with Fire 2009
Directed by Daniel Alfredson · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, Fandor
6.9
7.0 · 1.9K votes
47
Sheep Without a Shepherd 2019
Directed by Sam Quah · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Kanopy, AsianCrush
6.9
7.6 · 115 votes
48
Seobok 2021
Directed by Lee Yong-ju · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, Hoopla
6.9
7.2 · 269 votes
49
Montage 2013
Directed by Jeong Geun-seop · Streaming on The Roku Channel, Plex, Plex Channel
6.9
7.3 · 216 votes
50
Psych: The Movie 2017
Directed by Steve Franks · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Peacock Premium, Peacock Premium Plus
6.9
7.2 · 264 votes

Smart score = (votes × rating + 82 × 6.03) ÷ (votes + 82): the TMDB rating, pulled toward the catalog average as if every film had 82 extra average votes. Streaming data by JustWatch.

Hidden gems

Highly rated but with 49 votes or fewer (the median for this list), ranked with a lighter prior of 20 votes so smaller films can show.

1
Chithha 2023
Directed by S. U. Arunkumar · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Hulu
6.6
7.7 · 41 votes
2
Abducted: The Carlina White Story 2012
Directed by Vondie Curtis-Hall · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Kanopy, Lifetime Movie Club
6.5
7.8 · 33 votes
3
Haunted Harmony Mysteries: Buried at C 2025
Directed by Linda-Lisa Hayter · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, YouTube TV
6.4
7.8 · 18 votes
4
Rohan at the Louvre 2023
Directed by Kazutaka Watanabe · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
6.4
7.7 · 20 votes
5
C U Soon 2020
Directed by Mahesh Narayanan · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
6.5
7.2 · 46 votes
6
The Ainsley McGregor Mysteries: A Case for the Winemaker 2024
Directed by Martin Wood · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, fuboTV, The Roku Channel
6.3
8.1 · 13 votes
7
Ordinary Person 2017
Directed by Kim Bong-han · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, AsianCrush, Cineverse
6.4
7.2 · 44 votes
8
Air Murder 2022
Directed by Cho Yong-sun · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video
6.4
7.3 · 31 votes
9
DEEMO Memorial Keys 2022
Directed by Shuhei Matsushita · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, The Roku Channel, The CW
6.3
7.6 · 19 votes
10
Crisis Negotiators 2024
Directed by Herman Yau · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Plex, Plex Channel
6.4
7.2 · 33 votes