Best Thriller Movies on Disney Plus in the US

1. 1
   Girl in the Basement 2021

   Directed by Elisabeth Röhm · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu, Hoopla
   7.5

   7.6 · 906 votes
2. 2
   The Abyss 1989

   Directed by James Cameron · Streaming on Disney Plus, Philo, BBC America
   7.3

   7.4 · 3.6K votes
3. 3
   Stolen Baby: The Murder of Heidi Broussard 2023

   Directed by Michelle Ouellet · Streaming on Netflix, Disney Plus, Hulu
   7.0

   8.4 · 59 votes
4. 4
   The Old Mill 1937

   Directed by Wilfred Jackson · Streaming on Disney Plus
   7.0

   7.3 · 226 votes
5. 5
   Strange Days 1995

   Directed by Kathryn Bigelow · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Disney Plus, Hulu
   7.0

   7.0 · 1.6K votes
6. 6
   The Girl Who Escaped: The Kara Robinson Story 2023

   Directed by Simone Stock · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu, Hoopla
   6.7

   7.1 · 131 votes
7. 7
   Mexican Psycho 2026

   Directed by J. Xavier Velasco · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu
   6.7

   7.2 · 108 votes
8. 8
   Flowers and Trees 1932

   Directed by Burt Gillett · Streaming on Disney Plus
   6.6

   6.9 · 205 votes
9. 9
   The Finest Hours 2016

   Directed by Craig Gillespie · Streaming on Disney Plus
   6.6

   6.6 · 1.8K votes
10. 10
    Kraven the Hunter 2024

    Directed by J.C. Chandor · Streaming on Disney Plus, fuboTV
    6.4

    6.4 · 2.6K votes
11. 11
    Abducted by My Teacher: The Elizabeth Thomas Story 2023

    Directed by Shawn Linden · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hoopla, Lifetime Movie Club
    6.3

    6.9 · 44 votes
12. 12
    The Day Everything Changed 2024

    Directed by Javier Colinas · Streaming on Disney Plus
    6.3

    7.5 · 20 votes
13. 13
    Turner & Hooch 1989

    Directed by Roger Spottiswoode · Streaming on Disney Plus
    6.3

    6.3 · 1.5K votes
14. 14
    Girl in the Shed: The Kidnapping of Abby Hernandez 2022

    Directed by Jessica Harmon · Streaming on Amazon Prime Video, Disney Plus, Hulu
    6.2

    6.7 · 22 votes
15. 15
    Girl Taken 2025

    Directed by Paula Elle · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu, Hoopla
    6.2

    7.2 · 10 votes
16. 16
    Wrath: A Seven Deadly Sins Story 2022

    Directed by Troy Scott · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hoopla, Lifetime Movie Club
    6.1

    7.0 · 10 votes
17. 17
    A Kidnapping in Amish Country 2024

    Directed by Cat Hostick · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu, Hoopla
    6.1

    7.0 · 10 votes
18. 18
    Hidden Murder Island 2023

    Directed by Damián Romay · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hoopla
    6.0

    5.9 · 10 votes
19. 19
    The Moon-Spinners 1964

    Directed by James Neilson · Streaming on Disney Plus
    6.0

    5.9 · 61 votes
20. 20
    Captain America: Brave New World 2025

    Directed by Julius Onah · Streaming on Disney Plus
    6.0

    6.0 · 3.6K votes
21. 21
    Demon Inside 2013

    Directed by Alfonso Pineda Ulloa · Streaming on Disney Plus, Hulu
    5.9

    5.6 · 34 votes
22. 22
    Race to Witch Mountain 2009

    Directed by Andy Fickman · Streaming on Disney Plus
    5.8

    5.8 · 1.9K votes
23. 23
    The Haunted Mansion 2003

    Directed by Rob Minkoff · Streaming on Disney Plus
    5.7

    5.7 · 2.2K votes

Smart score = (votes × rating + 82 × 6.03) ÷ (votes + 82): the TMDB rating, pulled toward the catalog average as if every film had 82 extra average votes. Streaming data by JustWatch.